Amazedly - we are beginning the restful regain of our daily routines. With that comes some of the loveliest learning of all - learning about learning.
Today while reading and writing with the kids in our own sporadic program I was traying to just observe strengths and weaknesses. I have been trying to find a good home-school curriculum that will best fit my kids and help them soar in their abilities. I have found one that I love (looking at for the time being) for it's basis and emphasis on phonics. Yet, while working with Viv I finally realized the crux of the debate about Phonics vs Whole Word reading training.
If you follow education you will run smack into the middle of the debate over phonics and whole word reading styles. Whole word is also know as 'sight word' reading. The debate has gotten more heated since the infamous 'No Child Left Behind' mandate in education. Here's why (from my viewpoint):
Once the government mandated that there be a national standard for reading - teaching nation wide changed. The emphasis switched from the process of learning to the product of learning. And if you can reach the product faster - all the better for the national standard. Not to mention, but slightly, the fact that more of the overall teaching days were being eaten up in testing days to measure said set standard. A lot of public systems jumped to the 'whole word' approach of reading. In this method children become familiarized with a written word such as CAT and know that it represents the animal with fur and a tail that lays in the sun lazily all day long. They can memorized the shape and length of the word without actually having to sound it out to figure out what it is. This method works great with younger kids because they have a strong association memory with images. Before you know it your 1st grade class can read to 'standard' with only having to had drilled on flashcards with pictures.
I have naturally shied away from the 'whole word' approach because of its problems that present later in a kids life - that point around 14-16 when word recognition fails, they start to fail, and someone gets labeled with a disorder that really just means 'problem reading.' The labels are distructive and the kid is just lost. All's they needed early on where a few tools to know how to put words together, also known as Phonics. Phonics (or phonemes singular) are the sounds that each letter makes in any given language. As they go through the alphabet it doesn't nesecarily matter what the name of A is but rather that it makes the sound of someone being surprised and exclaming 'AHHHHH!" in most cases that it appears. Thus when coming upon the word CAT the child reads "Ckkkk"- "Ahhhhh"- "tttt" then run the sounds together until they hear the word CAT. I don't rightly know how the Phonics approach to teaching reading disappeared. I can't see why it would be harder to teach except that you do need to teach the majority of the phonemes prior to a child ever reading a word. Yet, once they get how to blend the phonemes together then they can read pretty much any word.
Bottom line is, all kids learn different, especially early on. Personally I have been more drawn to phonics and a latin based grammar system but today I started so see that I might need to draw in more sight words, or at least sight training. Here's the scenario that caught my eye:
Viv has been a wiz at learning the phonemes. She will catch herself when sounding out a word if she mis-sounds a letter. She can articulately put together a word with distinct sounds. The weird thing has been putting together a whole string of words in a simple sentence. She will get each word individually but by the time she has it the 3rd word she can't remember the other words she read because she has been so intent on the current set of letters. I have been attributing a lot of this to ADD symptoms (which we are still testing through a first diagnosis and wish to follow up with more testing...and that is a whole other story). Inattention to one word or fish like memory were the likely culprits. Nevertheless I was not willing to let it rest quite yet.
We were stuck on a sentence that she had not only identified every word in, but had just finished tracing and writing herself. She had used all learning styles with this sentence: kynisthetic, auditory, and visual. Reasoning says she should remember it. The sentence was "I CAN BAT A BIG BALL." She would sometimes trip on I making it's sound, which was just not paying attention. She always got CAN but tripped constantly on BAT. That one stumped me. BAT was the crux of the sentence - the verb, the action word that makes the rest of the sentence make sense. If the sentence was making sense to her at all. We kept going through and repeating various parts of the sentence always returning to BAT which was rarely remember as a whole word. She could sound it out each time, but just couldn't remember what that word was. Hmmph. Maybe she needed some drills with whole word?
I sat down next with Viv and pulled out some sight word flash cards we had. I wondered if I showed the word with the picture she would remember the shape of the word better. We had five words: RUG, PEN, TEN, HIT and WEB. Each word had similar shapes, except RUG. I worked with repetitive patterns or just one word with pictures. Sure, there was a lot evident of the inattentive issues yet there seemed to be a bit more of recognition of the word without having to sound it out after the first 15 minutes. She was recognizing the word shapes and allowing herself to trust her eyes instead of having to hear it with her ears (which, by the way, Viv is totally an auditory learner, if she can hear it she can remember it, the kind of child that can repeat the lyrics to a song after hearing it once). Her best word: RUG. I have to surmise because it looked more different than the rest.
I tested the same method with both Danny and Faith as they came in curious as to what was taking so much time with Viv. Faith thought it dull after reading through once and asked why I was repeating the same words (super visual child). She had memorized them after going through once. Yes, nine months more in age helps a lot. Danny got the words by the second time and relied a lot more on the pictures but then got lazy (as is his high fault with learning - motivation) if asked to do it twice. Then I went back to Viv - it was as if she had never seen the words before. She was more intent on checking on my reaction to her performance than testing her own intellect. Huh.
We ended our time learning together and then my learning started. This whole Phonics vs Whole Word thing was a puzzlement. I rolled it around in my brain for awhile until I remembered a similar debate that had been clarified for me once having children - Nature vs. Nurture. Prior to being a mother I could logically say that one side of the argument was more predominate, although never admit to just adhering to just once. Once having my own children I recognized that pitting one against the other in any philosophical realm was ridiculous. If you are having to choose one or the other you are missing the symetrey of using both - as they are BOTH right. Could it be that Phonics vs. Whole Word was just another teaching philosophy that was jumbling up what should BOTH rightly be used to teach a child to read?
My conclusion is YES. Yet again being a mother has taught me more about educational pedagogy than I ever learned in a college course for education. I won't say that the people that have come to such conclusive studies as to affirm that one is better than the other are foolish dummies - but I would put a bit of money on the statistic that none of them were mothers to multiple children. I have been schooled by my children better than any professor. Although, I must thank them for even introducing me to the contrasting contexts of teaching a child to read - otherwise I wouldn't have had anything to keep my brain occupied for 2 miles of treadmill running.